How do their growth rates compare?

Thumbfa.st has a month-over-month growth rate of +24.5%; ThumbnailMakerr has -44.1%.

How does pricing compare?

Thumbfa.st: Freemium, Paid. Freemium with paid tiers. Free includes 5 thumbnails, up to 2 at once, 10 inspirations and 2 persons, Gemini only, with a watermark on exports. Pro is about $19/month for 150 thumbnails, up to 4 at once, unlimited inspirations and persons, Gemini plus OpenAI models and no watermark. Ultra is about $49/month for roughly 500 thumbnails. Confirm current pricing on the site. ThumbnailMakerr: Freemium. Freemium. A free tier with 100 starting credits is advertised, no credit card required, alongside paid plans at roughly $15/month (Standard), $39/month (Pro), and $79/month (Ultimate), billed monthly or annually with monthly thumbnail and credit allowances. Verify current prices on the pricing page.

What are alternatives to Thumbfa.st and ThumbnailMakerr?

Other tools in related categories include Shutterstock AI Image Generator, Pixlr, Vheer, Image To Image AI, ImageGeneratorAI.io.

Thumbfa.st vs ThumbnailMakerr — Traffic (20.6K vs 4.58K), Pricing & Verdict

Open AI Tools

Thumbfa.st vs ThumbnailMakerr — Traffic (20.6K vs 4.58K), Pricing & Verdict | Open AI Tools

Side-by-Side Traffic & Specification Matrix

Dimension / Metric	Thumbfa.st	ThumbnailMakerr
Official Domain	thumbfa.st	thumbnailmakerr.com
Pricing Model	Freemium, Paid	Freemium
Monthly Visits	20.6K (20,603)	4.58K (4,580)
MoM Traffic Delta	+4.05K (+24.5%)	-3.61K (-44.1%)
Primary Market & Share	🇺🇸 United States (25%)	🇺🇸 United States (43.5%)
Direct Visits / mo	8.33K	1.84K
User Rating	4.2	4.1
Supported Platforms	Website	Website

Thumbfa.st

AI YouTube thumbnails with face consistency, style copying and A/B variants

Face-consistent Person profiles

Upload your photos once to create a reusable person profile so your likeness stays recognizable across every thumbnail.

Copy any thumbnail's style

Paste a YouTube URL and the tool analyzes that thumbnail's style, colors, text placement and mood, saving it as a reusable inspiration.

1-4 variations per generation

Produce up to four thumbnail variations in a single click so you can compare them side by side or A/B test.

Sketch-to-thumbnail editor

Sketch rough shapes, arrows and labels in the built-in editor and let the AI turn your layout into a finished thumbnail.

Strengths & Pros

+Face consistency removes the most tedious part of manual thumbnail design
+Template and inspiration copying turns strong competitor thumbnails into usable references
+Up to four variants per run supports genuine A/B testing
+Exports come out at the correct 1280x720 PNG with no resizing
+