How do their growth rates compare?

Thumblytics has a month-over-month growth rate of +18.8%; ThumbnailMakerr has -44.1%.

How does pricing compare?

Thumblytics: Paid. One published plan at US$999 per month covering four tests on videos selected jointly, with a 100% money-back guarantee on tests that do not win. No setup fees and no long-term contract. Confirm current pricing on the official pricing page. ThumbnailMakerr: Freemium. Freemium. A free tier with 100 starting credits is advertised, no credit card required, alongside paid plans at roughly $15/month (Standard), $39/month (Pro), and $79/month (Ultimate), billed monthly or annually with monthly thumbnail and credit allowances. Verify current prices on the pricing page.

What are alternatives to Thumblytics and ThumbnailMakerr?

Other tools in related categories include Shutterstock AI Image Generator, Pixlr, vidIQ, Vheer, ThumbnailCreator.com.

Thumblytics vs ThumbnailMakerr — Traffic (127.51K vs 4.58K), Pricing & Verdict

Open AI Tools

Thumblytics vs ThumbnailMakerr — Traffic (127.51K vs 4.58K), Pricing & Verdict | Open AI Tools

Side-by-Side Traffic & Specification Matrix

Dimension / Metric	Thumblytics	ThumbnailMakerr
Official Domain	thumblytics.com	thumbnailmakerr.com
Pricing Model	Paid	Freemium
Monthly Visits	127.51K (127,505)	4.58K (4,580)
MoM Traffic Delta	+20.19K (+18.8%)	-3.61K (-44.1%)
Primary Market & Share	🇺🇸 United States (28.3%)	🇺🇸 United States (43.5%)
Direct Visits / mo	30K	1.84K
User Rating	4.2	4.1
Supported Platforms	Website	Website

Thumblytics

Done-for-you YouTube thumbnail and title testing with a money-back guarantee

Done-for-you testing

The team designs, uploads, tests, and reports on every thumbnail and title variant, so you only review the shortlist and the results.

Native YouTube Test & Compare

Tests run inside YouTube Studio's own tool against real impressions and viewers, so results are measured rather than predicted.

Guaranteed outcomes

If the challenger loses or the test ends inconclusive, that test is refunded in full; winners stay live and keep earning.

Back-catalogue focus

Effort goes to existing videos where residual impressions and dated packaging make a repackage most likely to win.

Strengths & Pros

+Only pay for tests whose changes win, with a clear published guarantee
+Winners stay live permanently, so the lift compounds month after month
+Uses YouTube's own native A/B tool, giving measured results on your real audience
+Fully managed process: targeting, variant design, upload, testing, and reporting